By: Danny Jacobs
A few notes from day two of Baltimore City State’s Attorney Gregg Bernstein’s first trial as top prosecutor.
-My story today alluded to two, 55-inch flat screen TVs that were unused during the first day of the trial. Today, they briefly were used by defense lawyer Ken Ravenell to show a still of surveillance video of the West Baltimore corner where the three police officers are accused of kidnapping two teenagers.
-Ravenell finished up his cross-examination of one of the teens, Shawnquin Woodland, which lasted approximately three hours over two days. Most of the interactions followed the same pattern: Ravenell would restate something Woodland told the jury under direct examination; Ravenell would show Woodland the transcript of a statement the teenager gave during previous interviews with police or prosecutors that contradicted what he told jurors; Woodland would deny ever saying what was in the transcript.
Bernstein, when it was his turn to re-direct the witness, re-read portions of the transcript aloud with Woodland and concluded by getting Woodland to confirm, over defense attorney objections, he was telling jurors the truth.
Woodland seemed to give a lot of contradictory answers depending on who was asking the questions, but he always sounded certain in whatever answer he gave. In other words, he sounded like the 17-year-old kid he is. I can imagine the following exchange would resonate with the parents of any teenager:
Ravenell: Did he ask you about the transcript?
Woodland: Yes.
Ravenell: What did he ask you?
Woodland: Nothing.
-What I was most interested to see today were the actions of defense lawyer Dave Irwin, whose client is the only one who opted for a bench trial. Both Ravenell and Michael Belsky, who represented the third officer, hammered Woodland about his seemingly contradictory statements. But Irwin declined to cross-examine Woodland when given the chance and also turned down Judge Timothy J. Doory’s offer to ask questions following Bernstein’s re-direct.
While Ravenell and Belsky loudly and repeatedly objected during Bernstein’s re-direct, Irwin remained silent, occasionally jotting down notes. We’ll keep tabs on the bench trial/jury trial dynamic as the trial moves forward.
The prosecution will continue with its case Thursday afternoon.
Recent Comments