Quantcast
Icon

A Daily Record blog devoted to Legal Affairs

Law blog roundup: Back-to-school edition

By:

The kids are back to school and you’re at work. Take a minute to check out some law links to start the week.

  • Copyright laws might prevent public consumption of the Savory collection — a treasure trove of jazz recordings from the 1930s and 1940s.
  • Two couples with ties to the Maryland legal community made the New York Times Weddings/Celebrations page.
  • Virginia’s AG says the state can further regulate abortion clinics.
  • The Maryland Injury Law Blog is supporting sitting judges Laura Kiessling and Ronald Jarashow in the race for Anne Arundel County Circuit Court judge — even though they say only 11 people could make an informed decision in that race.
  • Lots of students on other career tracks work for free in summer internships, but law schools in Florida are refusing to post requests seeking summer associates who will work for free because of labor laws.
  • More and more are leaving big law behind.
  • The Huffington Post has a Q&A with Pastor Fred Phelps of the Westboro Baptist Church.

Category: Attorney General, Copyright, judges, law, law blog round-up, religion, Virginia

Silverman weighs in on alleged lacrosse killer’s defense

By:

Over at Silverman, Thompson, Slutkin & White’s Maryland Criminal Attorney Blog, Steve Silverman is criticizing early statements made by the lawyer for George Huguely, the University of Virginia lacrosse player charged with murdering his former girlfriend, Yeardley Love. Love, also a lacrosse player at the university, was from Cockeysville.

Huguely’s lawyer has made the following statement: “Until more information becomes available, it is our hope that no conclusion will be drawn or judgment made about George or his case. However, we are confident that Ms. Love’s death was not intended, but an accident with a tragic outcome.”

This is exactly the wrong way to go about the early stages of handling a case like Huguely’s, Silverman writes:

For the defense attorney to characterize this murder as an “accident” at this early stage only serves to enrage the public and the victim’s family as well as bait the prosecution to seek the death penalty. Also by tipping an early hand, the defense attorney has provided the police with the investigative road map they should take to focus on disproving this [poorly thought out] defense. The defense also hurt [its] chances of convincing anyone of a sincere insanity plea down the road by taking this approach.

Silverman also writes that the characterization of the killing as an “accident” will hurt Huguely because he allegedly burglarized Love’s apartment, kicking a door and taking her computer.

Now that a burglary has been committed, even if the death of Love was an “accident” as the defense attorney wants us to believe, it was a death that occurred during the course of a burglary. Any law student knows that makes a classic case for felony murder.

Category: Crime, law, Virginia

Gardner lawyers up

By:

The lawyer has become the client.

Baltimore attorney Paul W. Gardner II, who has made headlines as counsel for alleged White House party-crashers Tareq and Michaele Salahi, has now himself retained a lawyer.

The lawyer, Mark R. Dycio of Fairfax, Virginia, tells me that when the Salahis told the Today show that Gardner had invited them to a Congressional Black Caucus dinner in September–another event they were accused of crashing–Gardner became a witness in their case. As such, Gardner no longer represents the Salahis, Dycio said.

Stay tuned for a full story on the Gardner angle.

Category: D.C., entertainment, law, Virginia

The menu on Death Row

By:

Slate had an interesting story yesterday about the last meals of death row inmates in anticipation of convicted “Beltway Sniper” John Allen Muhammad’s execution last night in Virginia. (Muhammad chose not to reveal his last meal to the public.)

The Slate story provided links to the Web site of the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, which posted the final meals requested by offenders until 2004, and continues to post their final statements.  Psalm 23 appeared to be a popular choice judging by a random sample. (Muhammad “ignored a request” to make a final statement, according to news reports.)

The Texas sites are eerie and chilling. Delbert Teague Jr., for example, was executed in 1998 for murdering a Fort Worth man in 1985. He did not request a final meal, but at the “last minute he decided to eat a hamburger at his mother’s request,” according to records. His last statement was as follows:

I have come here today to die, not make speeches. Today is a good day for dying.

Est Sularus Oth Mithas (My Honor Is My Life).

As someone commented on the Slate story, “there is something disgustingly voyeuristic about it all.”

Category: Crime, Death penalty, food, government, law, Virginia

Female circumcision case interesting for another reason

By:

As if Caryn Tamber’s article weren’t compelling enough, our sister paper in Richmond points out another reason to study Gomis v. Holder.

“If the 4th Circuit’s current configuration leaves it in equipoise and publishing even fewer opinions than usual, it is at least going on the record with some of its disputes,” Deborah Elkins writes on the Virginia Lawyers Weekly blog

In recent days, the court has published two orders in cases in which it has denied rehearing en banc, with judges at each end of the spectrum publishing concurrences and dissents from those denials.

True, the judges don’t always fall into predictable patterns.  But their airing of views on classic issues such as the degree of deference to agency decisions and the “sanctity of the home” may be a preview of coming attractions, after some of the court’s five vacant slots are filled.

The agency-deference case Elkins refers to is Gomis, in which the court voted 5-5 not to rehear an asylum case. July’s panel decision deferred, 2-1, to the BIA’s finding that an adult woman’s father was unlikely to make good on his vow to have her circumcised because, among other things, the practice was outlawed in Senegal in 1999 and the State Department reports it is on the wane there. 

The “sanctity of the home” case is Hunsberger v. Wood, decided Sept. 14 by a 5-4 vote with one abstention. The decision let stand a finding of qualified immunity for a police officer who made a warrantless entry to a home at night, accompanied by a civilian who was looking for his missing stepdaughter.

 

Category: 4th Circuit, immigration, law, Virginia

What about the Widener seat?

By:

With the Senate Judiciary Committee poised to vote Thursday on Judge Andre Davis’ nomination to fill “the Murnaghan seat” on the 4th Circuit, Virginia’s senators have floated a name to fill “the Widener seat.”

Our sister paper in Richmond, Virginia Lawyers’ Weekly, says Senators Jim Webb and Mark Warner have recommended to President Obama that he nominate Justice Barbara Milano Keenan, currently on the commonwealth’s high court.

Plenty of empty spots to go around…

Category: 4th Circuit, judges, law, Virginia

Biker v. Insurance Company: The rematch

By:

From our sister paper south of the Potomac comes this story of a health insurance company that refused to pay on a $100,000 claim for a motorcycle rider’s injuries from a crash after he pleaded guilty to reckless driving, a misdemeanor. (He had been charged originally with drunken driving, Virginia Lawyers Weekly reported.)

Anthem Health Plans of Virginia figured there was no coverage because the General Provisions of its policy specify that it “does not cover any loss that results from the covered person committing … an illegal act.”

Roderick Bailey’s lawyer, though, argued that “illegal acts” is too broad a term to go undefined in the policy, which separately excludes the results of the insured’s felonies — under the “War” exclusion, 20 pages away from the General Provisions.

Misdemeanor reckless driving, by contrast, is essentially unintentional conduct, Bailey argues; and isn’t that what insurance is for? In other words, letting insurers deny coverage for unintentional conduct should be against public policy.

The lower court ruled for Anthem, which I’m told caused a stir among trial lawyers. Now, though, it’s the defense bar’s turn to worry: the Virginia Supreme Court has agreed to hear Bailey’s appeal.

A quick look online yields this similar case (pdf), decided in 2006 by a federal judge in Shreveport, La., but it’s hard to believe the situation doesn’t come up all the time. How do you think it would turn out here in Maryland?

Category: insurance, law, Virginia

Becoming a member of the Va. Bar takes stamina

By:

A friend of mine drove down to Richmond on Monday to get sworn in to the Virginia Bar.

After taking what some have said to be the hardest bar exam in the nation (yes, he told me that after the exam, even those who took the California and New York bar exams said Virginia’s was by far the hardest), the new admittees were subject to a new form of torture: an almost four-hour-long swearing-in ceremony.

Evidently, in Virginia, every single person must be named before the group swears to uphold the state and U.S. constitutions. And, not only is every single name read, the name of the law school each admittee attended is also read aloud.

My friend tells me that there had to be at least 3,000 people at the ceremony yesterday (he said he was eyeballing it, and in my experience, he doesn’t tend to exaggerate).

Three hours and 45 minutes later, the new admittees were finally released. I guess the Commonwealth of Virginia wants to make sure its attorneys know just how privileged they are to be members of the Virginia State Bar. It was certainly a ceremony my friend will never forget.

CHRISTINA DORAN, Assistant Legal Editor

Category: law, Virginia

Embracing the ‘Potomac Primary’

By:

hillary_martin_anthony.jpg

If you’re still getting used to the idea that your primary vote carries significant weight this time around, you’re not alone. I felt like I couldn’t escape the campaign ads all weekend.

Though predictions have been swirling about the impending “sweep” by Democrat Barack Obama and Republican John McCain, some voters are still undecided. Here’s your guide to the metropolitan-area movements of the presidential candidates today, in case you’d like to take one in:

BARACK OBAMA

  • Rally at the Comcast Center at the University of Maryland, College Park. Doors open at 10:30 a.m.; Free, public
  • Rally at the 1st Mariner Area, Baltimore. Doors open at 2:45 p.m.; Free, public; RSVP encouraged

HILLARY CLINTON

After speaking yesterday in Bowie, the District and Manassas, Va., here’s the Clintons’ schedule for today:

Hillary: Will tour the GM Allison Transmission Plant in White Marsh, Md. and will speak at UVA in Charlottesville, Va. She’ll also take part in a Politico/ABC7 forum this evening.

Bill: Will speak in Fredericksburg, Roanoke and Fairfax, Va.

JOHN MCCAIN

Have you already visited a local rally or speech? What were your impressions?

Above: Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton shakes hands with Maryland Gov. Martin O’Malley during a town hall meeting at Bowie State University in on Sunday, Feb. 10. (AP Photo/Baltimore Sun, Kenneth K. Lam)

JACKIE SAUTER, Web Editor

Category: Maryland, politics, Virginia

Animosity between Washington Post, Virginia bloggers?

By:

A NoVa blogger posted over the holidays about the “simmering animosity that has been developing between the Virginia blogosphere and the Washington Post.” According to Prince William Co. blogger bvbl, WaPo is pushing sources not to talk to Virginia bloggers, threatening to cut off coverage.

The Post did launch LoudounExtra.com recently, but the site links to other area blogs run by bloggers not affiliated with the Post. They also have a “sponsored blogroll” on the bottom of the main post.com home page that links to blogs that participate in the ad sales program.

Why would WaPo do that if it felt blogs were competition?

JACKIE SAUTER, Multimedia Editor

Category: Virginia, Washington Post

Email Alerts

Sign up for free email alerts from The Daily Record

Enter your e-mail address:
Morning News Update
TDR Auction Notices
Real Estate Weekly
In-House Counsel Monthly