Quantcast

Where are your witnesses?

The courtroom opens at 8:30 a.m. for the 9 a.m. criminal docket. The public defenders check in around 8:15 a.m., at which point the state extends plea offers. Although the PDs play for the other team, their challenges do not go unnoticed. Two PDs are assigned to a courtroom. Each PD may be assigned as many as 15 cases a day. That may seem manageable compared to our 20 to 40 cases; however, when considering the personal attention each client requires, it can be overwhelming. To minimize the workload, PDs often note our plea offer before witnesses check in, haggle over the offer and try to persuade us to nolle the case. If they can’t convince the state to nolle the case outright, then we wait to see which witnesses check in for the day. In fashioning an appropriate plea offer, we often consider what the defendant gets and what the state gets by the defendant’s guilty plea. In admitting guilt, the defendant is relieving the state of its burden of proof. The state does not have to put on any evidence, the witnesses do not have to sit in court all morning waiting for their case to be called and the court does not have to sit for an afternoon trial. While on its face it may not appear as if that is relieving the state of much, the burden of proof can be enormous.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*