Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Gary S. Williams: Options for saving for your child’s education

Gary S. Williams: Options for saving for your child’s education

Listen to this article

A college education is one of the best investments you can make for your child’s future. But the high cost of college may alarm you — especially if you’ve waited too long to begin saving.

For example, a Coverdell Education Savings Account (formerly referred to as the Education IRA), with its annual contribution limit of $2,000, won’t offer much help if your child is already in high school. And prepaid tuition plans are attractive, but only if your child is willing to attend a school that participates in the plan.

Fortunately, there’s another option for your college savings plan. Created in 1996, state-sponsored college savings plans (or Section 529 plans, after the IRS code that created them) allow flexibility in choosing a school and the opportunity for late starters to make sizable investments while reaping tax breaks.

How they work

Section 529 plans allow individuals to invest in a predetermined pool of stock and bond investments. Most plans will require you to divide your investment according to a given asset allocation determined by your child’s age. In general, the asset allocation will be more aggressive for younger children and less aggressive for children nearing college age.

Lifetime contribution limits to Section 529 plans vary from state to state, but often exceed $200,000, and offer some flexibility on when you can contribute. In addition, there are no income thresholds and typically no annual contribution limits, although annual contributions of more than $13,000 ($26,000 when made jointly with a spouse) may require filing a federal gift tax form.

You may contribute five years’ worth of gifts all at once, or $65,000 per beneficiary, without triggering the federal gift tax. All earnings in the account grow tax deferred. If you live in the state where the plan is administered, you also may be eligible for state tax deductions.

Once your child reaches college age, the account owner may withdraw money from the account to pay for qualified higher education expenses. Assuming that you have followed the plan’s rules, there will be no penalties (nonqualified withdrawals are subject to a 10 percent penalty in addition to ordinary income taxes). And qualified withdrawals are tax free (prior to 2002, withdrawals were taxed at the child’s rate).

If there is money left in the account, the beneficiary designation can be changed to a sibling, first cousin or other family member (as defined by the Internal Revenue Code) of the original beneficiary without triggering gift taxes.

Pros and cons

Flexibility in contributions and college choice are the biggest advantages of Section 529 plans over other tax-deferred college savings vehicles. Even though these plans are state-sponsored, you do not need to be a resident of the state to participate, although you may lose out on state tax benefits by participating in an out-of-state plan.

Apart from tax savings, these plans offer the advantage of professional asset management. Each state contracts with a single asset management firm to oversee the plan, so by comparing various state plans, you’ll be able to choose from several professional management companies.

For more information on each state’s plan, visit This Web site includes graphical ratings that compare the plans and links to plans that have Web sites.

The primary drawback to Section 529 plans is investment risk. Unlike state-sponsored prepaid tuition plans, returns from Section 529 plans are not guaranteed. This means that your investment could lose value, perhaps just as your child is beginning college. Although the firms that manage Section 529 plans use less-risky asset allocations to reduce risk as your child nears college, risk cannot be eliminated altogether.

You’ll also want to have a thorough understanding of contribution and withdrawal rules before investing in a plan, since rules vary depending on the state. Pay particular attention to rules regarding transfers, early withdrawals or withdrawals for things other than college expenses. Penalties are imposed if withdrawals are not used for qualified higher education expenses (generally 10 percent on earnings only).

Choosing the best option

Section 529 plans are just one of the options you have for college savings. They offer a great deal of flexibility in exchange for a higher level of investment risk. If you’re getting a late start or if your child is unsure of which college he or she wishes to attend, a Section 529 plan may be your best choice.

But if you’re starting early on saving for college, you might consider a prepaid tuition plan. This plan allows you to lock in today’s tuition rate, which can mean a savings of thousands of dollars in college costs. Prepaid tuition plans guarantee payment of a semester’s tuition for each unit that you buy, and payments may be spread out over several years.

Almost all prepaid tuition plans are more restrictive when it comes to choosing a college, and they may also be more restrictive in terms of withdrawals. Applicants will typically receive a list of participating colleges that a child can attend. If the child wishes to go to a school outside the plan, the value of the investment may be reduced.

Coverdell Education Savings Accounts allow you to set aside money each year toward a child’s education. The contribution limit is $2,000. Withdrawals for qualified higher education expenses are tax free, and account balances can be transferred to siblings without any tax consequences so long as it is done prior to the previous beneficiary’s 30th birthday and the new beneficiary is under the age of 30.

While tax benefits make these accounts attractive, the low contribution limit may not provide enough money to pay for college. Unlike state-sponsored plans, income limits apply for eligibility. Only single filers with incomes of less than $110,000 and joint filers with incomes of less than $220,000 are eligible.

As with any financial planning decision, the choice that’s best for you will depend on your unique situation, including your risk tolerance and the number of years until your child begins college.

Another consideration is your child’s plans. Does he or she even plan on attending college? If so, has he or she chosen a school? Talk with your child about college, then make an appointment with your financial advisor to find the plan that best suits your needs.

Gary S. Williams, CFP, CRPC, AIF, is president of Williams Asset Management at 8850 Columbia 100 Parkway, Columbia, Md. He is an investment adviser representative with/and offers securities and advisory services through Commonwealth Financial Network, Member FINRA/SIPC, a Registered Investment Adviser. He can be reached at 410-740-0220 or [email protected]. This communication is strictly intended for individuals residing in the states of: Arkansas, California, Colorado, Delaware, Florida, Kansas, Massachusetts, Maryland, Maine, Michigan, Missouri, North Carolina, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia, Wisconsin and West Virginia. No offers may be made or accepted from any resident outside these states due to various state requirements and registration requirements regarding investment products and services.

Networking Calendar

Submit an entry for the business calendar