Judges may bar experts from testifying when their methodology is flawed but may not exclude testimony because the judges disagreed with the data, court says.

Tagged with: admissibility Daubert expert testimony Frye-Reed scientific testimony

The Court of Appeals is weighing the continued admissibility of ballistics testimony.

Tagged with: ballistics Daubert Frye-Reed toolmark

Maryland's top court will weigh if the science linking fatal bullets to specific guns cases survives the court’s new standard for judging scientific testimony.

Tagged with: ballistics Daubert Frye-Reed guns toolmark

The Maryland Court of Appeals has told a trial court to review whether the long-accepted courtroom science linking fatal bullets to specific guns in homicide cases withstands the high court’s recently adopted standard that permits emerging and contrary scientific theories ...

Tagged with: ballistics Daubert Frye-Reed toolmark

Two Maryland high court judges have taken the unusual step of sharply criticizing their colleagues for declining to reconsider their decision last month that permits judges to admit into evidence scientific conclusions based on emerging theories that have been peer-reviewed ...

Tagged with: Daubert Frye-Reed motion to reconsider

A divided Maryland high court has opened trials to a broader range of science-based testimony than that which is “generally accepted” among scientists, ruling that judges may admit into evidence scientific conclusions based on emerging theories that have been peer ...

Tagged with: Daubert Frye-Reed scientific testimony

If the DNA test is good enough for the FBI, it’s good enough for us, Maryland’s top court says in upholding a double-murder conviction and double-life sentence.

Tagged with: dna fbi Frye-Reed

A criminal defense attorney urged Maryland’s top court Thursday to overturn a double first-degree murder conviction because it was based on an unreliable DNA test, while an attorney for the state pressed the judges to defer to a trial court’s acceptance of the genetic evidence linking the killer to the slayings.

Tagged with: dna Frye-Reed